Madison-area sellers often hear that winter is a bad time to list. Last winter's Dane County numbers show something more specific. Buyers did pull back after fall, but the number of homes for sale fell almost exactly as fast. In September 2025, closed sales equaled about 44% of the homes on the market. By January 2026, after months of cold weather and holidays, that share was about 43%. Most of the competition left along with the buyers. The month when a seller's odds actually improved was February.
That matters this year because the market heading into winter looks different from last year's in two ways. The supply of homes is fuller, and mortgage rates are higher. If you own a home in Madison and are deciding between a January listing and an April one, the useful comparison is how many homes sell in a given month against how many are listed.
The Realtors Association of South Central Wisconsin publishes Dane County inventory and sales each month. Its January 2026 report tracks last season's decline. Active listings in the county were 1,175 in August 2025, 1,115 in October 2025 and 1,061 in November 2025, and they reached 728 in January 2026. From September 2025, when the county had 1,137 active listings, to January, the supply of homes fell by about 36%.
Closed sales fell by almost the same share. Dane County recorded 498 sales in September 2025 and 312 in January 2026, a drop of about 37%. That gives January sales equal to roughly 43% of active listings, essentially the same as September's 44%. A home listed in January 2026 was competing for a smaller pool of buyers, but against a proportionally smaller group of other homes.
January also had more new supply than sellers often expect. The county added 564 new listings in January 2026, slightly more than the 557 in January 2025, while 312 sales closed. Many sellers chose to list in the first month of the year.
The pattern changed in February. Dane County's active listings fell again to 683, and sales rose to 364, up about 17% from January, according to RASCW's February 2026 report. February sales equaled about 53% of active listings, the first clear gain of the season. February was also the month with the fewest homes for sale of any month in the series below.
Spring was much stronger than any winter month. The table shows how the season played out, using RASCW and South Central Wisconsin MLS monthly figures for Dane County. The last column is sales divided by active listings, rounded.
| Month | Active listings | Closed sales | Sales as share of active listings |
|---|---|---|---|
| September 2025 | 1,137 | 498 | about 44% |
| January 2026 | 728 | 312 | about 43% |
| February 2026 | 683 | 364 | about 53% |
| April 2026 | 801 | 590 | about 74% |
| May 2026 | 956 | 694 | about 73% |
| June 2026 | 1,016 | 821 | about 81% |
| September 2026 | 1,322 | 524 | about 40% |
In April, May and June, sales equaled roughly three-quarters or more of the active listings each month, even though new listings ran between 823 and 881 a month. Spring is still when the most homes sell. Fall and January performed about the same. The real seasonal gap was between winter and spring, and it began narrowing in February.
RASCW's September 2026 report, released Oct. 19, shows a fuller market than last fall. Dane County had 1,322 active listings in September 2026, up 16.3% from 1,137 a year earlier and up from 1,214 in August 2026. Sales rose too, to 524 from 498 in September 2025, but more slowly than listings. As a result, September 2026 sales equaled about 40% of active listings, the lowest share in the table.
The Wisconsin Realtors Association county figures for September 2026 point the same way. Dane County averaged 85 days on market, up from 80 in September 2025, and had 4.3 months of inventory, according to the WRA's September housing report. The WRA measures inventory differently from RASCW, so treat its months of supply as a separate measure from RASCW's listing counts.
If Dane County's supply fell by the same share this winter as last, the 1,322 listings from September would drop to roughly 850 by January. That would still be more than last January's 728. A listing that goes up this fall and stays active without selling carries over into winter as competition. A homeowner choosing between November and January is choosing whether to compete with that group now or after part of it has sold or been withdrawn.
The usual case for waiting is price, and the statewide research supports it. In the WRA's December 2025 report, consulting economist Dave Clark said that from January 2005 through December 2025, Wisconsin homes selling between December and February were "discounted about 5.9% on average," and homes selling in June, July and August carried "an average premium of about 6.4%."
That figure covers the whole state, and it measures closings. Part of the winter discount comes from the types of homes that close in winter, and part comes from contract timing, since a home that closes in January often went under contract in November or December. In Dane County, January 2026's median sale price was $437,750, up 4.2% from $420,000 in January 2025. The county's year-to-date median through September 2026 was $470,000. Some of the gap between those two numbers reflects the season, and some reflects which homes sold in each period. A well-presented house in a sought-after part of Madison does not automatically lose 5.9% because it was listed in January.
Mortgage rates are the clearest difference between this winter and last. The WRA's September 2026 home sales report put the average 30-year fixed rate at 6.86% for September 2026, up 51 basis points in a year and the highest since January 2025. In the same report, WRA President and CEO Tom Larson said higher rates "keep potential sellers from listing their homes because they don't want to give up the very favorable rates locked in over the last six years."
That affects both sides of a Madison seller's math. Buyers pay more to borrow, which the WRA links to the 2.4% statewide decline in September sales. Other owners who might list are also staying put. Statewide new listings fell 5.1% from September 2025 to September 2026. Dane County's new listings followed, at 631 in September 2026 against 646 a year earlier. The rise in Dane County's total supply comes from homes staying on the market longer, not from a wave of new sellers. Fewer new listings in winter would help someone who lists in January.
Rates could also go either way over the next few months. In the same WRA report, Clark noted the Federal Reserve's recent 25-basis-point increase and said a December hike "would not be surprising if core inflation does not move downward." A seller who waits until April is betting that spring demand will outweigh whatever rates do between now and then.
These figures suggest three possible timelines for a Madison homeowner who plans to sell within the next six months.
Listing in late fall puts a home on a shelf that had about 16% more listings than last fall, with September 2026 absorption at its lowest point of the year. Listing in January means competing with whatever is left from that fall supply, but last year's numbers show buyers left the market at about the same rate as listings, so January did no worse than fall. Listing to be fully ready by late January or early February puts a home in front of buyers just as last year's sales share began to rise, with a smaller field of competing homes than spring will bring.
The third timeline needs the most planning. A home that is photographed, repaired and staged before February has to be prepared in December and January, during the holidays and short daylight, which is when pre-listing work through Compass Concierge would need to be scheduled. Some sellers will still choose spring, and the 73% to 81% absorption from April through June supports that choice for homes that need the largest possible pool of buyers. Their competition will be larger too, with 801 to 1,016 active listings each month last spring.
These are countywide figures, and a single street or price range can run ahead of or behind them. Condos are one example, and our look at Madison's resale-driven condo market covers that part of the market separately. More on the city itself is on our Madison neighborhood page.
If you are weighing a January listing against an April one, Susan Sutton Homes would be glad to talk through which date fits your home and how much preparation each one leaves room for. Request a Complimentary Home Valuation & Concierge Plan to start that conversation.
Don't navigate the world of real estate alone. Let Susan Sutton be your advocate on the path to finding your dream home or selling your current property. Susan is dedicated to making your real estate journey seamless and rewarding.